Colin Firth and Toni Collette in HBO Max’s ‘The Staircase’: TV Evaluation

No votes

If you happen to’ve been feeling like each week this spring has seen the discharge of at the least one restricted collection that strongly resembles a documentary, information characteristic or podcast you as soon as loved, you’re not unsuitable.

And should you’re getting somewhat fatigued with these reveals, wherein too regularly nothing is added aside from Emmy-hungry actors enjoying dress-up, you’re not alone.

The Staircase

The Backside Line

Rises above the true-crime pattern.

Airdate: Thursday, Could 5 (HBO Max)

Solid: Colin Firth, Toni Collette, Michael Stuhlbarg, Juliette Binoche, Dane DeHaan, Olivia DeJonge, Rosemarie DeWitt, Tim Guinee, Patrick Schwarzenegger, Sophie Turner, Vincent Vermignon, Odessa Younger and Parker Posey

Creator: Antonio Campos


Nevertheless, “telling the identical story” and “truly being based mostly on supply materials” are very various things — and nonetheless adored a few of these true crime/true fraud docs and podcasts may need been, none of them are The Staircase.

Launched in 2005 on Sundance Channel within the U.S., Jean-Xavier de Lestrade’s eight-part collection was Serial earlier than there was Serial, The Jinx earlier than there was The Jinx. It didn’t actually invent a style, nevertheless it codified a construction of shifting sympathies, whiplash twists and wild evidentiary reveals which were adopted numerous instances subsequently. There was a decade throughout which The Staircase was troublesome to seek out, after which it reappeared on Netflix together with 5 extra episodes that lacked the craftsmanship and gravitational pull of the unique, however at the least made that unique broadly out there.

The documentary, and simply not its story of the homicide of Kathleen Peterson and trial of her husband Michael, is central to HBO Max’s eight-episode The Staircase. It’s the meta examination of the best way the true crime style constructs, captures and distorts the precise reality that elevates creator Antonio Campos’ method right here — usually within the vein of his chilling ripped-from-headlines characteristic Christine — from suave, star-studded reenactment, to one thing regularly provocative. I solely say “regularly,” as a result of by way of the 5 episodes despatched to critics, the 2 sides of the story don’t at all times work with equal effectiveness, and there are occasions when all sides feels prefer it’s barely dragging down the opposite.

As a refresher: The Petersons appeared like Durham, North Carolina’s good blended household. Michael (Colin Firth) was an writer and occasional political candidate, endlessly supported by spouse Kathleen (Toni Collette), an government at Nortel. Their photogenic brood featured sons Todd (Patrick Schwarzenegger) and Clayton (Dane DeHaan) and daughters Margaret (Sophie Turner), Martha (Odessa Younger) and Caitlin (Olivia DeJonge).

The veneer of home bliss was shattered in 2001 when Michael known as 911 claiming to have discovered his spouse’s physique on the backside of a staircase after she allegedly took an unintended tumble. Michael was shortly arrested for her homicide. Was he a cold-blooded killer or focused by regulation enforcement due to essential feedback he made in his native newspaper column?

As particulars had been being unearthed, a French movie crew (Vincent Vermignon and Frank Feys as variably fictionalized variations of Jean-Xavier and producer Denis Poncet) arrived on the town and got full — maybe too-full — entry to most of the case’s key figures, particularly Michael.

I do know it’s most likely too late for me to let you know this, however one of the simplest ways to look at HBO Max’s The Staircase might be to have seen the documentary a number of years in the past. That method you’ve sufficient of a way of the story to understand how Campos, author of the premiere and director of all the episodes I’ve seen, and co-showrunner Maggie Cohn are constructing the thriller equally, whereas nonetheless being considerably shocked when secrets and techniques and variations emerge.

There are layers of nice dramatic irony that come from being conscious of sure items of knowledge which are held again — issues of Michael’s sexuality, the parentage of every of the youngsters, particulars from their respective pasts — and seeing how they’re being held again from family members, numerous attorneys, the documentary crew and viewers.

The collection, which is interweaving as many as three totally different timelines directly, concurrently explores how a case like this might stretch over 16 years and engages in narrative elongation of its personal, with reenactments of the tragedy and shifts in perspective that push every episode to over an hour. Episodes really feel packed however by no means padded, and whereas there’s an exhaustion that comes from the regular crawl of grief, there’s constant substance past the distress porn.

It helps that there are various questions which are extra urgent than merely, “Did Michael do it?” Though I’m by no means going to cease questioning what The Staircase would have appeared like with unique star Harrison Ford, Firth nails Michael’s inscrutable insincerity. Even should you’re sure he’s mendacity about almost the whole lot, you possibly can spend a very long time questioning why he’s mendacity and if being a compulsive liar means he’s a killer. Although Kathleen is underwritten, Collette inhabits the character sufficient that she’s extra than simply the lifeless spouse and instigator of the story.

There’s a number of underwriting happening with characters that the documentary didn’t fairly perceive both. Michael Stuhlbarg, bouncing again after miscast or complicated performances in Your Honor and Dopesick, is equal elements calculating and incredulous as Michael’s lawyer David Rudolf. I want there was extra effort to flesh out the case’s prosecutors: Cullen Moss has little to play as Jim Harden and Parker Posey is left with a personality outlined solely by a thick Southern accent that she makes use of to generate some very needed laughs.

The choice to deal with the documentary crew extra as composites than characters isn’t an issue once they’re actively filming within the first 4 episodes. However when the fifth episode focuses extra closely on their post-production course of and them as folks, you notice they’ve neither personalities nor voices.

In watching the documentary, I truly turned much less keen on Michael and extra within the polarized allegiances of his youngsters. That’s additionally one of the best a part of the later chapters of the collection; the performances by Turner, Younger and DeHaan finest exhibit the toll this highlight may placed on an already splintered household.

Consciousness of the documentary offers sufficient context to right away see how Campos is visually paying tribute to the aesthetic established by Lestrade, and the place his prospers are his personal. Working freely round a wonderful recreation of the Peterson dwelling, Campos generally makes use of a vérité fashion and even grainy video inventory to make viewers really feel like voyeurs at household dinners and technique conferences. However then there are sequences of cinematic artificiality — a reminder, in case you wanted one, that this was already a documentary as soon as and didn’t have to be once more. The second episode has an distinctive intercutting sequence between the protection crew’s strategizing and reenacting within the Peterson home and a metropolis council fundraiser in the home a yr earlier, the digicam dancing balletically between the scenes generally linked inside a single complexly patched-together shot.

With three episodes left unseen, I’m going to be interested in how Campos and Cohn deal with the documentary, its influence on the eventual appeals and on the style going ahead. Lots of that could be realized by way of a personality performed by Juliette Binoche, who, so far, positively hasn’t been given sufficient to do to justify the half being performed by, you already know, Juliette Binoche.

I’ll even be curious how the collection goes to deal with the “Owl Idea,” a supposition so weird the documentaries didn’t even know what to do with it. It speaks properly for the present that even after having watched this story for 13 unscripted hours, I nonetheless have a lot left I need to see right here.

Doing a scripted present about an already nice piece of artwork is basically powerful. I provide you with Paramount+’s The Supply as a current failed instance. Thus far, The Staircase is an effective collection about an incredible documentary, nevertheless it has the potential to turn into superb within the dwelling stretch.

Posted on:
Genre: Reviews

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.